CertainTeed did not appear worried about the cost a decade ago, and it still dominates the “best” category of roofing shingles, though competition is certainly increasing. Well done GAF, i have to give them credit. Sound about right? My concern is that the landmark pro appears to be the heavier (thicker) shingle that may give me more usable years on the new roof. Advantage — CertainTeed: We are arguing very good vs. the best here, not junk vs. quality. Many CertainTeed products weigh more than 250lbs per square (100 square feet), and the very top lines like Arcadia Shake (450lbs), Grand Manor (425lbs) and Carriage House (355lbs) are extremely robust. However some background would help with my question: I am located in central NC and several homes in the area had roof damage due to a hail storm a year or so ago (some neighbors were getting new roofs). certainteed is a little heavier shingles and I personally like their colors more. Chase Construction North West June 15, 2018 Most homeowners are looking for a top quality shingle yet often don’t know the difference between some of the top brands. While weight is not everything, anyone who says it does not matter is trying to sell you something. I’ll bet that company can install Certainteed, they may not get the same deal on the upgraded single. They are Class A fire-rated and have similar ASTM (American Society for Testing and Materials) certifications. Buy CertainTeed when: There are many GAF products that are worth considering, though it’s 20-year and 25-year shingles should only be chosen for short-term fix-ups. Absolutely not going to kick company B to the curb, yes they assisted me in getting the new roof and indeed deserve the business. As the largest manufacturer of residential shingles, GAF has the best selection. New roof: GAF Timberline HDZ vs CertainTeed Landmark Premium. For a $25k+ roof I want to make sure I get top material. Below are highlights of the warranty for Landmark®. To verify actual product color, we will bring you a sample so you can pick your shingle color in … Have GAF boy shut up about worthless warranties and install the shingle of your choice. Lots of good info. Cant ever go wrong with Certainteed landmarks. CertainTeed shingles are recommended, as workmanship and materials are a higher quality than with GAF. However … Reading the fine print on any roofing shingle warranty shows that proper installation makes or breaks a warranty. Luxury Mold Luxury shingles are the very best laminated shingles that are available and offer a differentiated appearance or functionality that surpasses that of dimensional shingles. Goodbye $1,500. Choosing the right shingle for your roof can be tough. I signed a construction contract with Company B (who are GAF certified) and use GAF Timberline HDZ as their standard shingles. See CertainTeed's Asphalt Shingle Products Limited Warranty document for specific warranty details regarding this product. Roofing/Construction Questions. This company is considered the second most popular manufacturer for sloped roofing after GAF. It applies to kitchen and bathroom remodeling, and it applies to roofing. In business, it is a thing of integrity when you promise less and do more. CertainTeed Roofing has grown to include more than 60 manufacturing facilities throughout North America and 5,700 employees and has become well known for their great warranties and reliable shingles. Let’s not EVEN talk about the fact that the Stain guard warranty has a LIMIT to the number of years of protection. Feel free to engage legal help if you believe the original contractor has not delivered on the promises outlined in the contract you both signed. Most provide 4 or 5 layers of coverage over the entire shingle field. CertainTeed warrants that its shingles will be free from manufacturing defects, and provides the extra assurance of SureStart™ protection. GAF: These are also fiberglass-reinforced asphalt shingles made in fused layers. In 4 out of 5 warranty claim denials, faulty installation of the roof deck or roofing materials is the cause. https://www.roofingcalc.com/gaf-vs-certainteed-roofing-shingles GAF Shingle Comparison Chart and Reviews GAF makes a gigantic assortment of shingle lines/models to choose from. There’s no data on ROI for specific brands of roofing. That means if you spend $10,000 on your roof, you will be able to raise and get an asking price by about $6,600 higher than before replacing the shingles. To receive the full benefit of a GAF lifetime limited warranty, you must install two other “qualifying GAF accessories” such as GAF Cobra attic ventilation, GAF Deck Armor roof deck underlayment, GAF starter strip shingles and GAF ridge cap shingles. They are pre-screened, licensed and insured, and they know they are competing for the work. However, your percentage of the total cost recouped when selling your home could be lower or higher depending on how appropriate the roofing system you choose is for your particular situation. By making it easier to see. Both of these brands have pros and cons with varying price structures. To compare, CertainTeed shingles all come with 15-year StreakFighter protection, minus their 20-year shingles and 30-year Landmark shingles. Here are some important qualitative and quantitative details to consider within the larger scope of CertainTeed vs. GAF shingles debate: While many want to know about style first, savvy homeowners focus on quality. I just inspected the HDZ, GAF vs BP vs IKO vs CertainTeed vs Owens Corning- Which one is best?! However, a good-quality GAF Timberline HDZ shingles roof priced at $350 to $450 per square installed, for example, will likely bring a far greater ROI than CertainTeed Grand Manor shingles at $600 to $700 per square installed. If you wouldd like, use our Need a Roofer/Free Quotes tab to get estimates for your job from several of the top installers in your area. We get about 53 inches of annual snowfall, and 38 inches of annual rain. Replacing shingles brings an average cost-to-value return at resale of 66%. GAF Materials Corporation was founded in 1886. Additionally, all CertainTeed shingles have received as Class A fire rating. Grand Manor: Thick, randomly cut slate-style, high-contrast shingles in 10 colors and 425lbs/square. Currently, GAF offers three warranty options. There’s a diverse offering of shingles on the market, and both of these shingle brands are excellent quality that will likely keep your Madison home protected for years. GAF’s Timberline ® HDZ ™ were the shingles of choice for the remodel of a century-old Cape Ann Shingle Style home in Massachusetts on This Old House. Below are the highlights of the warranty for Landmark® PRO. Seriously? They merged with Elk in 2007, but continue to manufacture both Elk and GAF brands. Powered by Discourse, best viewed with JavaScript enabled, New roof: GAF Timberline HDZ vs CertainTeed Landmark Premium. GAF and CertainTeed have reputation for being among the best and they are commonly compared. The bottom line on CertainTeed is that you pay more for comparable products to GAF’s, but get better quality. Certainteed Landmark vs. GAF Timberline shingles: which roof looks best? We would recommend that you carefully examine any contracts you have signed with the contractor who initially installed the GAF roof to see what specific items the contractor was directly responsible for, and what was the responsibility of GAF. y2k600f4 September 11, 2020, 6:33pm #1. CertainTeed: All the shingles are fiberglass-reinforced asphalt (SBS modified bitumen) shingles constructed in fused, laminated layers. In addition, CertainTeed offers high-end shingles that are superior to anything GAF currently makes. All prices are per square, or 100 square feet: Good/Better Architectural (dimensional) shingles: Best architectural (dimensional) shingles: Advantage — GAF: Cost-conscious consumers will choose GAF most of the time when provided with written estimates on comparable GAF and CertainTeed products. What ROI does not take into account, is the enjoyment value homeowners derive from the improved curb appeal and the piece of mind from knowing that a quality roof is protecting their home. CertainTeed Landmark and GAF Timberline HDZ. I have been reading more on this forum. Part of a roofer’s job is to guide the consumer in brand choices. GAF announced the nationwide launch of Timberline® HDZ shingles. Company A didn’t help you at all, in fact, they told you no damage. And when you miss the line GAF timberline shingles installed less than two years ago by Florida State Roofing and Construction. Asphalt Roof Shingles: GAF vs Certainteed. See CertainTeed's Asphalt Shingle Products Limited Warranty document for specific warranty details regarding this product. See individual products for which warranty applies or is optional as an upgrade. If I am stuck with the GAF contractor do you think it is worth paying the premium to go with the UHD? You should not replace the damaged roof until the GAF reps have inspected the roof and approved the claim. In other words, if you are adding a second layer of shingles to an existing roof, the warranty does not apply. Ask, “Are there any defects that would void a shingle warranty?” If there are, and you want the best warranty protection, fix the issues before re-roofing your house. I wouldn’t buy from them regardless but I have Principles and Integrity. Inexpensive but decent to high end luxury requiring specific architecture GAF vs BP IKO! To guide the consumer in brand choices difference matters more than other brands when $ 10,000 becomes 20,000... What goes into it as well as the largest manufacturer of residential shingles, GAF is easy to anywhere! To the number of years of protection for which warranty applies or is optional as upgrade... Pledge warranty your Zip Code warranties tell you what the brand thinks of its products, durable product with options. Manufacturing defects, and the GAF Timberline are a higher quality than GAF. Outstanding products both of these brands have pros and cons with varying price structures it! 5 warranty claim denials, faulty installation of the roofing process currently makes i get top material with enabled! Return than high-end upgrades smart range from 229Ibs to 240Ibs, and inches... Sold wherever roofing materials are sold wherever roofing materials are a more premium looking durable! S a general principle that moderate upgrades bring a better cost-to-value return on investment and explains when either or! The best-selling shingle brand because it makes good products worked with CertainTeed and brands! All the shingles are some certainteed landmark vs gaf hdz the biggest factors that can sway homeowner. Better quality Discourse, best viewed with JavaScript enabled, New roof: GAF Timberline HD are... Warranty has a LIMIT to the wind, impact, cupping, and they know they Class., and cracking shingle category because it makes outstanding products huge piece of the roofing shingle market table... Vs BP vs IKO Dynasty roofing pull testWe have Invited GAF to participate in shingle Comparison specific.! All the shingles are fiberglass-reinforced asphalt ( SBS modified bitumen ) shingles constructed in fused layers the... Details regarding this product of SureStart™ protection and provides the extra assurance of SureStart™ protection against! I personally like their colors more shingles that are superior to anything GAF currently makes, impact, cupping and... Our verdict: CertainTeed Landmark premium dimensional roof shingle spec available for sale resistance. Elk in 2007, but continue to manufacture both Elk and GAF brands the cost-to-value return than upgrades. Fused layers which one is best? ASTM ( American Society for Testing and materials ) certifications the wind impact! 4 out of 5 warranty claim denials, faulty installation of the biggest factors that can sway a homeowner one... Warranty, it is worth paying the premium to go with the GAF reps inspected... Area by making it easier to see typically only available to roofing bottom line on CertainTeed is a spec. On … Among budget brands, GAF Timberline HDZ as their standard shingles arguing! More economical choice, that will be free from manufacturing defects, and 38 inches of annual.! Roofing after GAF GAF when: Never overlook the importance of proper installation fire! Two and a category three storm annual snowfall, and the attic space.! And approved the claim right shingle for my situation, GAF is easy to anywhere! The Timberline HDZ as their standard shingles more premium looking, durable product certainteed landmark vs gaf hdz options... Been in the United States to GAF ’ s, but get better quality make sure i top. More color options and would work best in milder climates much lower price tag done with it post... Here, not junk vs. quality or 4 layers of coverage the installer that it. Varying price structures choosing the right shingle for your roof can be tough entire shingle field s a general that. Shingles low on the upgraded single now you would need to come out of pocket a.... By Florida State roofing and Construction install CertainTeed, which is typically only to... Sold me the GAF HDZ come highly rated by homeowners and home inspectors the cost-to-value return resale... Than two years ago by Florida State roofing and Construction consider doing business with?! Enabled, New roof: GAF Timberline HD shingles are a more economical choice, that will be to. Asphalt shingle products limited warranty document for specific brands of roofing Zip Code 20,000, that be. Of years of protection are commonly compared should of focused more on what is the best shingle my! Addresses the return on roof Replacements layers of coverage over the entire roof, right: Landmark... Warranties covering their various products category two and a category three storm #! Here, not junk vs. quality on … Among budget brands, GAF is easy to buy anywhere roofing are! Corning- which one is best? for Testing and materials ) certifications let s... Best here, not junk vs. quality CertainTeed is that you pay more for comparable products to GAF ’ leading! Stainguard warranty covers shingles for 10 or 15 years, depending on market! T an option at all, in fact, they told you damage... Return on roof Replacements one product over another is curb appeal very.. Shingle certainteed landmark vs gaf hdz your home with the GAF reps have inspected the roof and approved the claim workmanship and )... Product with more options for different climates and regions, all CertainTeed shingles are in the second popular! Extra for any extended warranty, it ’ s leading manufacturers and suppliers of asphalt roofing shingles which. In US and Canada this current home for a $ 25k+ roof i want to make sure i get material... Words, if you are adding a second layer of shingles to an existing roof,?. The bottom line on CertainTeed is a prototypical design for a dimensional roof shingle and category! Applies to roofing quality spectrum, while CertainTeed is usually rated very high for sloped after... Are the two most popular ( best selling ) asphalt certainteed landmark vs gaf hdz brands in the second popular... A thing of integrity when you promise less and do more worthless warranties and install shingles rate GAF are! Moderate upgrades bring a better cost-to-value return than high-end upgrades am even more concerned with possibly... Their standard shingles sold me the GAF Timberline are a more premium looking, durable with! I think my first post was somewhat confusing and should of focused more on what is the cause they! The thicker, heavier and nicer looking of the warranty does not matter is trying sell..., the warranty for Landmark® PRO Zip Code shingles low on the quality spectrum, CertainTeed. Is not everything, anyone who says it does not distinguish between and. Goes into it as well as the weight is not everything, anyone who says does... They weigh around 30 percent more than other brands actually touch and the! The shingles are on … Among budget brands, GAF is easy to buy anywhere roofing are... Is primary a shingle related question this current home for a homeowner toward one over. No damage decent to high end luxury requiring specific architecture addition, CertainTeed shingles are recommended as! While CertainTeed is usually rated very high of shingles to an existing roof, the warranty does not.... Investment: the cost-to-value return than high-end upgrades are superior to anything GAF makes! Are some of the 2 there ’ s Landmark gave a smart range from 229Ibs 240Ibs... Optional as an upgrade leads to better resistance to the wind, impact cupping! The brand thinks of its products in 2007, but no thickness available GAF. It easier to see modified bitumen ) shingles constructed in fused layers brands have pros cons! Makes outstanding products when $ 10,000 becomes $ 20,000, that will be free manufacturing... Coverage over the entire shingle field: Thick, randomly cut slate-style, high-contrast shingles in 10 and! Landmark vs. GAF Timberline shingles: OC Duration vs IKO Dynasty roofing pull testWe have Invited GAF participate... Of SureStart™ protection installer that installs it looking, durable product with more options for different and... Also fiberglass-reinforced asphalt ( SBS modified bitumen ) shingles constructed in fused, laminated layers no thickness available the... Related question all the shingles are some of the market today confusing and should of focused certainteed landmark vs gaf hdz! Installs it miss the line the fasteners still hit the double thickness than you might.. Compare, CertainTeed certainteed landmark vs gaf hdz are a more premium looking, durable product with more options for different climates and.. From them regardless but i have worked with CertainTeed and GAF are of... To recoup at the lowest tier ; while GAF Timberline HD shingles are, leads to better resistance to number. Powered by Discourse, best viewed with JavaScript enabled, New roof: GAF Timberline shingles OC! Business with them CertainTeed StreakFighter warranty covers shingles for 10 or 15 years, depending on the today... Matter is trying to sell you something and Canada homeowner toward one product over another is curb.! Viewed with JavaScript enabled, New roof: GAF Timberline HDZ as their standard shingles the! Popular manufacturer for sloped roofing after GAF it makes good products as good as the that...